The Best First Aid Kit for Young Children

Having the perfect first aid kit on hand means your family can worry more about fun activities and less about any small emergencies that may occur. We researched dozens of pre-made first aid kits over 15 hours, and tested in real life by watching the reactions of kids to the cute characters; we even stuck a bunch of bandages on boo-boos to see just how well they adhered to nature’s most sticky surface: busy toddlers. We spoke with a school nurse and a pediatrician to get advice on what is commonly recommended for inclusion in a first aid kit. After all that, the Me4kidz Medibag Family First Aid Kit won out as the best choice for most parents.

Who should buy a first aid kit?

A pre-made first aid kit—or even a few of them—is a must have for any family. We compared the possibilities of a pre-made first aid kit to a do-it-yourself homemade first kit. Both are great options, although a pre-made kit is certainly simpler. (As you’ll see further in our guide, a hybrid—a pre-made kit supplemented by DIY additions—is often the best.)

Families with allergies, special medical needs or specific preferences on materials to use in first aid situations (like using natural herbs or essential oils instead of an antibiotic cream) may prefer going the DIY route. This will allow you to include items like epinephrine pens, prescription medicines, liquid pain or fever reducers (for children that can’t yet swallow pills), clay diffusers, or all-organic products. Our selected kit has plenty of stash room for your chosen extras.

For the everyday consumer, being able to quickly grab a pre-made first aid kit and trusting it has everything they would need is a big convenience. It’s commonly recommended that a family have a large selection of first aid items easily available to parents (but safeguarded against children) in a central location of their home and any home the children spend more than a few hours at regularly. A smaller portable first aid kit should also be stored in any vehicle that frequently transports the family. Finally, a smaller, travel version of a first aid kit should also be included in a diaper bag or purse when the family is out and about. Our selection is inexpensive and compact enough to be stashed anywhere in the house, although it’s too large for a diaper bag; we’d suggest DIY for your run-and-gun kit.

what makes a good first aid kit?

First aid is old—ancient even. The earliest recorded evidence of dressing wounds is from 500 BCE, as depicted on classical Greek pottery. While essential materiel in warfare, the concept of the first aid kit developed further as families made long treks toward new homes and distant lands. For millenia people were faced with hardships like snakebites, diseases, rough terrain, and heat exhaustion while on the road. Traveling clerics and doctors packed potions and tinctures in vials, as they saw fit; the basic process in treating minor wounds has remained largely intact, even if we no longer use lint, animal grease, and honey. The first patent issued for a modern pre-made first aid kit was applied for in 1942 by Clementine F. Campiglia. (And there were certainly pre-made kits before that.) It looks very similar to first aid kits available today, albeit with a little more leather.

Since it’s unlikely you’ll need supplies for battle or long trips across the Oregon Trail—but you do you!—what should you include in a DIY first aid kit or look for in a pre-made version?

We first reached out to Lauren Meyer, a mom and school nurse in St. Louis. She provided us with an awesome list of the items she uses most often and keeps on hand for minor emergencies.

This list includes:

  • alcohol wipes (or other type of cleaning wipe)
  • about 20 regular size bandaids
  • a few each of 2” by 2” and 4” by 4” gauze pads
  • medical cling wrap to keep the gauze pads in place
  • two clean cloths
  • a full water bottle for rinsing wounds
  • a small bottle of hand sanitizer
  • 2 pairs of latex-free gloves
  • a small thin scarf to be used as a temporary sling or tourniquet while waiting on emergency crews.

Mrs. Meyer advised holding off on the ointments: “I generally do not put antibiotic ointment on unless it is necessary. I do not want to expose someone to an antibiotic if it is not needed. A good cleaning of the area is usually enough unless someone will be away for a long period of time, such as a camping trip, where an abrasion could start to show the signs of infection.”

Many pre-made kits include an antibiotic ointment. That’s fine. It has its uses. We still recommend adding it to your own kit. Just remember there’s no need to use antibiotic ointment prophylactically for every little cut and scrape. Common topical triple-form antibiotic ointments like Neosporin may even contribute to the evolution of drug-resistant strains of more dangerous bacteria, like MRSA, over time.

We also spoke to Dr. Hansa Barghava, an Atlanta pediatrician and mom, who suggested that in addition to usual items like bandages and alcohol wipes, a first aid kit for children should include “small toys or a short book for distraction, in case you do need to go to the doctor quickly or your child is in pain. Children’s acetaminophen or ibuprofen is always good for pain and an ice pack. Lastly, allergic reactions do happen, so I would recommend some children’s Benadryl with a dosing cup as well, just in case you child breaks out in hives after eating something that you didn’t know she was allergic to.”

Our own research has shown information contrary to the advice of Dr. Barghava in relation to using acetaminophen for pain. In 2011, the DrGreen.com website reported, “the FDA’s Nonprescription Drugs Advisory Committee and Pediatric Advisory Committee have together recommended that ‘pain relief’ be removed from the label of Tylenol for babies and toddlers and other brands of acetaminophen because there is no reliable evidence that it relieves pain better than placebo in children under age two.”

You can expect to pay anywhere from $5 to $100 for a first aid kit or the supplies needed to make your own. Many first aid kits are priced higher, typically when chocked full of a large number of contents. Check the label carefully to ensure that the item is giving you a variety of needed supplies and not just an abundance of bandages. In most cases, you won’t need 20+ bandages in one accident. (And if you do, you have bigger problems on your hands!) First aid kits can always be refilled. We prefer to save money up front for a kit that has more obscure items like different sizes of bandages, treatment for bee stings or allergies, cleaning supplies, and a good case.

How we tested

Since the business of boo-boos is quite an unpredictable one, testing for the best first aid kit was a little different than how we normally test. We first narrowed down the market of first aid kits to ones in a reasonable price range. (Under $30.) We then compared the included items on the remaining first aid kits’ lists against the recommendations of our experts. For those that made the cut, we did hands-on testing. We used the bandages and alcohol wipes in a few real-life scrapes and cuts with our own kids, and we covered ourselves with bandages in the toughest places to see just how well they lasted. (You know, things like elbows and fingertips and knees.) We ripped the bandages off like we would a child as well—quickly. (They all hurt a little bit; no front runners there!) Any item in the first aid kit that we could physically open to test, we opened. There were a few things we couldn’t test (such as bee sting ointment) because we weren’t faced with that emergency—and Joel doesn’t pay us to hunt down bees—but we did open the packets to ensure frustration-free opening. In addition to this, we researched what other users were saying about the first aid kits and tried to replicate any complaints we’d heard.

Our Pick

Specifications

  • Dimensions: 12.3 x 9.3 x 6.8 inches
  • Weight: 1.5 pounds
  • Composition: plastic

Kit includes:

  • (12) Assorted kid-friendly bandages
  • (12) junior bandages
  • (12) 3/4″ X 3″ sheer bandages
  • (2) knee and elbow bandages
  • (2) Fingertip bandages
  • (20) Antiseptic sting-free wipes
  • (6) 2 X 2 gauze pads
  • (6) 3 X 3 gauze pads
  • (1) Anti-itch ointment
  • (2) Antibiotic ointments
  • (1) sting relief pad
  • (1) Burn gel
  • (1) First aid guide
  • (1) instant cold pack
  • (2) hand sanitizer packs
  • (2) blue kid-friendly exam gloves
  • (1) plastic disposable tweezers
  • (10) applicator cotton swabs
  • (1) emergency information label
  • (20) kid-friendly fun stickers
  • (1) 45 item refill kit coupon

After many hours of research over several weeks of comparison and testing, I am confident that the Me4kidz Medibag Family First Aid Kit is the one to buy; it best matches the needs of an everyday user with quality items and is available at a very reasonable price.

In addition, the Medibag has a child-proof (and yes, sometimes a little adult-proof) hard case with a lot of extra room, making it the only one we tested that gives you the ability to add those extra speciality items your family may need while still keeping everything securely in a single place.

There is room for your daughter’s Epi-Pen or your son’s teething gel. There is enough room to add the few things the kit doesn’t include that experts (including the CDC) recommend as well, like surgical gloves or possibly a mylar blanket, which some competitors include in their kits but this one does not. (You can pick up a 20-pack of mylar blankets for 12 bucks and stash them in your cars, if you want.)

While many of the items included in this 117-piece kit are bandages, the Medibag makes sure you will have a lot of different types of them, including ones specifically designed for fingertips, small spots, knees and elbows. These are kid-friendly bandages with fun prints to help your little one smile after falling down and matching stickers to distract or reward them for being brave. In addition to bandages, the Medibag includes an instant cooling pack, burn relief cream, sting relief cream, antibiotic ointment, cotton swabs, hand sanitizer, sting-free alcohol wipes, and gauze pads. It comes with an emergency family information label and, as an added bonus, an available free 45-piece refill kit to build up your supplies again when needed.

The price on the Me4kidz Medibag Family First Aid Kit is great, too. At under $15, it’s hard to find such variety for less money.

An extra plus: Me4kidz is family-owned and operated in the United States. The kit is made from recycled, lead-free plastic. Furthermore, Me4Kidz has teamed up with a non-profit organization to provide employment to disabled citizens. Not only does Me4kidz offer a great product, they seem to have a highly respectable corporate philosophy.

The biggest complaint we’ve found about the Medibag is how hard it is to open and close. Since it is a child-proof case, this is true, but its latching mechanism isn’t too difficult for adults—I certainly feel that a secure latch is better than one of my little ones getting ahold of something that would be harmful if ingested. From my testing, I do not believe this factor would make the first aid kit too difficult to open during an emergency.

who else likes it?

TheBraggingMommy.com says about the Medibag, “I needed to find a first aid kit that not only was stocked BUT that [my daughter] can’t get into. That is where medibag from me4kidz comes into play. Let me tell you how much I love this first aid kit… it is awesome!” She goes on to include that the idea of keeping stickers in a first aid kit is genius and that the reward of a sticker is her childrens’ favorite part of going to the doctor. “First Time Mom… and Losing It” reviewed the Medibag as well as said, “me4kidz does all the work for you by putting everything you need in a kid-friendly doctor’s bag. It is made of durable plastic that is easy to open.”

Users on Amazon have been a little brusque in their reviews. Overall, the Medibag has a rating of 3.6 out of 5 stars with nearly 60 reviews. User, “Jenny Johns” writes, “I am a pediatric ICU nurse and I couldn’t think of a better product to protect children. The medibag has all one would need, whether it be to fix a cut or respond to emergency situations.” One critic of the first aid kit writes, “All of the packaging for the supplies looks the same. So in a hurry, you might grab antibacterial ointment instead of burn cream. The packets are small and hard to open. The supplies are relevant and my kid doesn’t freak out when he sees it though.” This user still gave the Medibag 3 stars. Unfortunately, many of the small amount of users who rated the first aid kit at just 1 star did not give descriptive reasons for their low ratings.

The Me4kidz Medibag Family First Aid Kit has been featured in dozens of magazines including the Health and Beauty Care Executive, Buyer’s Guide: Pregnancy and Newborn, and Brand Packaging. Me4kidz has won awards for its product line as well such as the iParenting Media award, the Preemie Cool Stuff award and the Family Choice Award. They’ve also received the National Parenting Center seal of approval.

if you want to do it yourself

As we mentioned above, making a homemade first aid kit is also a very good option. We ultimately decided on the Me4kidz Medibag Family First Aid Kit because of the convenience and price but there are plenty of benefits to creating a do-it-yourself kit as well. You can pick your favorite brands of ointments, bandages and medicines or omit those types of things completely if first aid takes on a different meaning for your family.

The cost of a homemade first aid kit varies on your preferences. You’ll want to be sure to store everything securely in one place. Start out with a heavy duty gallon sized ziploc bag or go to your local dollar store and get a shoebox size plastic container with lid. If finances are a concern, you can stock up on a few items at a time, spending just a couple dollars with each trip to the store so it isn’t noticeable.

If you’d like to take your first aid kit to the next level for your family, ready.gov offers an extensive family emergency plan to be prepared for any situation, disaster or emergency. They recommend keeping this large kit in the lowest level, in the most interior space of your home. It is also recommended to have a version of this kit in any vehicle you travel in with your family. The extensive emergency preparedness kit includes having extra outfits for every member of the family, flashlights, batteries, and food and water for up to 72 hours. Think of this type of kit being what you need for basic survival in the event that a major catastrophic event happens in your neighborhood. In addition to the items Mrs. Meyer and Dr. Barghava recommended, the CDC offers an expanded list of what you should include in your first aid kit with items like a saline eye wash, thermometer, anti-diarrhea medicines, laxatives, scissors and/or aspirin.

Specifically for planning with children under the age of two years old, you may want to consider adding things to your first aid kit like powdered milk or formula, diapers and wipes, an extra bottle, diaper rash ointment, and extra blankets.

The Competition

We considered these commonly available competitors but ultimately can’t recommend them:

A variety of other options were excluded similar to this one by AAA which is designed to be an emergency road assistance kit and includes extras like jumper cables and a flashlight as well as this type of kit by ResCue 1st that is marketed for emergency preparedness in relation to natural disasters and features items like whistles, particle masks and a poncho.

care, use, and MAINTENANCE

Maintaining a first aid kit, especially the Me4kidz Medibag Family First Aid Kit, is extremely simple. As a best practice, replace any creams or ointments you use as soon as you have an accident so you’ll never be stuck without an important item. Refill the bandages and gauze once the supply gets low. Me4kidz makes this easy by offering a free refill kit. (You just pay shipping.)

Do bear in mind that most of the creams and ointments in a first aid kid will eventually expire; each packet has an individual expiration date printed on it. (You might set a calendar reminder for 2 years to go through and check, which is the expiration date for the kit after the date of manufacture.) Hot temperatures can accelerate the loss of efficacy, too, so a kit that’s left in the trunk of a car may need to be refreshed sooner.In the event that your case gets dirty, since it’s made of durable recycled plastic, it can be wiped down or disinfected with any of your favorite kid-safe cleaning products.

While there is no specific warranty period for the Me4kidz Medibag Family First Aid Kit, the company states on their website, “Me4kidz prides itself on customer satisfaction [and] wants you to be happy with your purchase. If you have any questions or concerns about anything, please contact us [and] we will do the best to satisfy your needs.” You can contact Me4kidz by calling their customer service line at (480) 444-2332 or submitting an online form.

Your Guide: Heather Campbell

Heather Campbell is a freelance writer, blogger and social media coordinator with a degree in business administration. She is married with three daughters and enjoys reading, running and bicycling as her escapes from a busy day. 

Sources

  1. Michelle Feliciano, me4kidz Medibag Family First Aid Kit, "First Time Mom...and Losing It!", August 21, 2014
  2. Clementine Campiglia, U.S. Patent US2324194 A, July 13, 1943
  3. Amanda Whatley Lee, Travel Health Kits, CDC.gov, August 1st, 2013
  4. Basic Disaster Supplies Kit, Ready.gov, June 10th, 2014
  5. Kissing away those boo boo’s with the Medibag from Me4kidz, The Bragging Mommy, September 12th, 2014
  6. Alan Greene, Tylenol No Longer Deemed a Pain Reliever for Babies & Toddlers, DrGreene.com, March 2015
  7. Allison Aubrey, Why It's So Easy To Give Kids The Wrong Dose Of Medicine, NPR, November 30th, 2010
  8. David Martin, MRSA in U.S. becoming resistant to over the counter ointment, CNN “The Chart”, September 14th, 2011

Expecting? We’ve made it easy:

Add All (Or Some) to Cart

Also on The Nightlight

Reviews

Articles